"Yeah I thought of that. Well not the my life sucks and I hope I could get away." Because mostly Buffy knew Vengeance Demons were around to hear you make a wish - hence her not saying wish right then. "But that there has to be a reason. I thought maybe we've got something extra or do something out of the norm and that's why. Kind of like a collection - but I couldn't narrow down what we all had in common."

While she didn't still think Ethan was behind it, she did think it wasn't a benevolent/good thing that they were all there.