When the drinks came, she wasn't sure she had an answer about the ingredients. "I.. how is it shiny?" She was trying to figure out the liquid and she brought it up to her face, sniffing, but sniffing just made it more confusing because it smelled kind of like... milk?

She put it to her lips, ready to take the tiniest of sips because, what could go wrong, really? Except there was a cat person who was pointing at her and she paused. Had she done something wrong already?

Slowly the glass lowered back to the counter, but then her eyes widened because, "W-what?"

Her eyes moved from the cat person to Peter in a 'did he really say that?' and then back to the cat man because, what?